Editor's Note: For more of my thoughts on WWE Unforgiven, check out Episode 110 of PWB's Official Podcast...
Here's a recent history of my viewing of WWE PPVs:
1. Wrestlemania 23 -- $50 invested. It was worth about $20. Good match between Undertaker and Batista, and good match between Cena and HBK albeit with a disappointing ending for HBK marks. Outside of that, nothing to write home about. Nowhere near as good as Wrestlemania 22, which was just off the charts.
2. Backlash -- $0 invested. I did happen to catch the last two matches, and they were pretty darn good. Some people are called this the best PPV of the year, but that seems like a stretch.
3. Judgment Day -- $40 invested. It was worth about $5. Absolutely nothing on this card stood out. Well, maybe the fact that John Cena actually made Khali watchable for about eight minutes.
4. One Night Stand -- $40 invested. This was total crap. To even label this "Extreme" is a joke. The one good match on this show was the Ladder Match between The Hardys and WGTT, and even that didn't hit expectations. I ordered based on the previous two One Night Stands, and was sorely disappointed. This is when I got really upset with WWE PPV for the second time (the first was after December to Dismember).
5. Vengeance -- $0 invested. This was actually in my home state, and I didn't even go to it. It wasn't even worth downloading one match, based on the reviews. I felt good about not even wasting my time on this one.
6. Great American Bash -- $0 invested. Again, didn't watch it, felt good that I didn't. Bobby Lashley v. John Cena? YAWN. Khali v. Kane v. Batista? That HAD to be a botchfest. What a joke.
7. Summerslam -- $0 invested. I caught the main event, and it delievered, although Superman retained his title much to the chagrin of the IWC. Outside of that match, this card was a joke, as well. Summerslam is always one of my favorite PPVs, and it pains me to see what it's become over the past few years.
That brings us to last night's WWE PPV offering, Unforgiven. As you guys know, I was
excited to order this PPV. In fact, I thought the WWE had a good card set up. Boy did I turn out to be WRONG (again). Here are my thoughts, in chronological order:
-- It's totally shocking that a "major" title match would open the PPV. Wait, I guess the ECW Title isn't considered "major" now that Booby Lashley's not holding it. ECW has become a complete joke.
-- Wow, turns out ECW has become even more of a joke than I thought. The challenger for their world title doesn't even get a televised entrance. That's hometown jobber-level, right there. The sad thing is, this was actually one of the best matches on the show, but the WWE could care less. Why even bring ECW back if you are going to treat it like this? I feel really sorry for Punk, who looked genuinely moved to have been booked into the ECW Title. Does he realize that his title means nothing in the eyes of the fans? Let's hope they move him off ECW quickly. He's earned it.
-- Matt Hardy and MVP kept the momentum going on PPV after a solid opening contest. This storyline is getting even more heated. My question is, how much longer can they make it go? Eventually, the storyline will end with Hardy winning the US gold. Then what will we have to look forward to on Friday nights? Undertaker v. Batista, part 67?
-- Triple H v. Carlito almost went down how I wanted it to. That is, until Triple H mind-bogglingly no-sold powder to the face. That made NO SENSE. That match should have gone a few more minutes, with Trips selling the crap out of the powder but then managing to overcome it. Instead, he gets hit in the face with powder, and actually seems to wrestle better. So much for not burying Carlito.
-- Wow, Beth Pheonix loses. Only JSN over on thenewpwb.com saw that coming. Props to him. I thought for sure Beth Pheonix would take the gold. Let's hope she gets it next month. I think King is secretly attracted to her. I bet he likes the "big girls."
-- What the hell was Khali's translator yelling after he squashed the fruit? And what's the preoccupation with cantaloupe on WWE TV, these days? Next time, let's move him out of the melon family. I'd like to see him squash a large coconut. Or Todd Grisham's head. Wait, I haven't seen Todd lately. Was he on the Signature Pharmacy list?
-- Batista v. Rey Mysterio has to happen. That would be an excellent feud. I'm totally convinced of it. I guess we're not going to get it, though.
-- Where does Khali go from here? A title rematch on Smackdown, which he will, of course, lose? Seriously, without the title, this guy has no direction. And that's not a good thing.
-- Why do people (such as
PW Torch's James Caldwell, who is perhaps more negative than me) constantly say that London and Kendrick are "a trainwreck?" I don't get it. That tag title match was awesome, and I can't wait to see this feud continue.
-- The PPV really went downhill with that John Cena/Randy Orton finish. That's inexcusable. I'll say it again: people don't pay $40 to see some shitty DQ ending. It's horrendous booking, and whoever is responsible for it needs to be drug into the street and stoned with large, sharp rocks. I despise thee, Raw booker.
-- Undertaker v. Mark Henry was actually WORSE than I thought it would be. It turns out this PPV was nothing more than $40 to see a really elaborate Undertaker entrance. Don't get me wrong, that's cool and all, but I really don't want to pay $40 for that. In fact, it's kind of insulting that the WWE thinks they can throw out some snazzy entrance and trick all of their fans into thinking that they saw a good match. I now believe this to be a generic WWE writer's interpretation of a WWE fan's thought process:
*DONG* *UNDERTAKER MUSIC* (Massive Pyro, burning crosses, fog, and lightning on entrance set)
WWE FAN: OOOOH, SHINY OBJECTS GO BURN! ME LOVE TAKER! THIS PPV GOOD!
Clearly, the Memphis fans were not fooled by this crap, if the "TNA" chants were any indication. If somebody's chanting "TNA" at your shows, you're REALLY putting on a BAD product. REAALLLLY bad.
-- Bottom line: the last two matches killed off what could have been a pretty good PPV. Usually, I don't let one or two matches sway my overall opinion of a show, but the DQ ending in the WWE Title match and the horrible main event soured me on this show. Maybe not the worst PPV of the year, but certainly the most insulting to fans who spend their hard-earned cash on WWE shows and merchandise. Guys and gals, if you're tired of being treated like this...just don't buy it! Maybe we can start a PPV Anonymous support group, or something. I'd be a founding member.